Home » Latest » Headlines » Newlywed Off-Duty Police Officers Stop Robbery At Restaurant

Newlywed Off-Duty Police Officers Stop Robbery At Restaurant

2

InfoSearched 50 0 Headlines

8.2

SaveSavedRemoved 0

A quiet dinner at Raising Cane’s turned into a foiled stickup the moment two off-duty cops spotted the gun.

Detective Chase McKeown and Officer Nicole McKeown were six months into their marriage and deep into a weekly date-night ritual when a masked gunman walked into their dinner. The Elizabethtown Police Department couple had picked a table at the back of a Raising Cane’s Chicken Fingers inside Louisville’s Mid City Mall on the night of Saturday, February 15, 2020. Neither was in uniform, but both were carrying, and within seconds of the gunman drawing on the cashier, they were on their feet.

• Around 10 p.m. on February 15, 2020, off-duty Detective Chase McKeown and Officer Nicole McKeown — married six months, both with the Elizabethtown Police Department — stopped an attempted armed robbery at a Raising Cane’s in Louisville’s Mid City Mall.
• Surveillance video showed the couple draw their own sidearms and move on the suspect, later identified as 30-year-old Justin T. Carter, who dropped his gun and ran without taking any cash.
• The McKeowns chased Carter down several blocks into the Highlands neighborhood and held him at gunpoint until LMPD 5th Division officers arrived; Carter was charged with first-degree robbery, receiving a stolen firearm — the weapon had been stolen from Jeffersontown police — and possession of a handgun by a convicted felon.

A Routine Date Night at Raising Cane’s

The McKeowns had made date night a fixture of their marriage, a habit rooted in their church and one they kept even on a weekend as ordinary as this one. They chose seats toward the back of the restaurant, out of the way, with no reason to expect trouble. Chase and Nicole had actually met on the job years earlier — he working patrol, she serving as an agency dispatcher — before their relationship led to marriage and, eventually, to Nicole joining him on patrol duty.

That history mattered once the robbery started. A masked man walked through the door, approached the counter, pulled a handgun and demanded cash from the cashier. For most customers in that dining room, it would have meant diving for cover. For the McKeowns, it meant recognizing exactly what they were looking at and reacting instantly.

The Moment the Training Took Over

Surveillance cameras inside the restaurant captured the sequence: the couple noticing the gunman, standing, drawing their own off-duty weapons and closing the distance on him before he had a chance to grab any money. Startled by two armed officers converging on him from inside a room he thought was full of ordinary customers, Carter dropped his firearm on the floor and ran out the door empty-handed.

Speaking afterward, Officer Nicole McKeown said their police instincts simply kicked in the moment they saw the weapon — there wasn’t a discussion, just a shared read on the situation and a shared decision to move. It’s the kind of split-second calculation that off-duty officers train for but rarely have to use, not unlike the instincts that led passengers to subdue an off-duty flight attendant making threats near a cockpit in a separate incident.

Startled by the armed officers, Carter dropped his firearm and bolted from the building without obtaining any cash.

The Chase Into the Highlands

The McKeowns didn’t stop at the front door. They followed Carter outside and tracked him several blocks away into Louisville’s Highlands neighborhood, holding him at gunpoint until marked units from LMPD’s 5th Division arrived to make the formal arrest. Louisville Metro Police confirmed the recovered handgun had previously been stolen from the Jeffersontown Police Department, adding a second firearms charge on top of the robbery count.

Carter, 30, was ultimately charged with first-degree robbery, receiving a stolen firearm, and possession of a handgun by a convicted felon — a combination of charges that reflects both the attempted holdup and his prior record. It’s the sort of case that, without two customers happening to be trained, armed officers, might have played out very differently, the kind of split-second armed encounter that echoes cases like the shootout involving a 12-year-old boy and 14-year-old girl that made headlines for how quickly routine calls can turn into gunfire.

LMPD Releases the Footage

Louisville Metro Police made the surveillance video public on February 18, three days after the incident, and used the release to single out the McKeowns for their response. Robbery investigators with LMPD credited the couple with acting decisively and heroically, noting that their intervention likely prevented the robbery from escalating and got a stolen firearm off the street in the same motion.

For a pair of newlyweds who met because one of them was working dispatch for the other’s patrol shifts, the whole episode landed as a strange kind of full-circle moment — six months into a marriage built around police work, they ended up making an arrest together on what was supposed to be a night off.