Home » Latest » U.S. » Michigan commissioner censured for attending stay-at-home protest

Michigan commissioner censured for attending stay-at-home protest

4

InfoSearched 73 0 U.S.

8.3

SaveSavedRemoved 3

A suburban Detroit commission just handed down a rare rebuke over one masked-less afternoon in Lansing.

Royal Oak City Commissioner Kim Gibbs is refusing to back down after her colleagues voted 5–2 to censure her for showing up, without a mask and without social distancing, at the April 15 “Operation Gridlock” protest against Governor Gretchen Whitmer’s stay-at-home order. The vote capped a marathon virtual meeting that stretched nearly six hours into the early morning of April 28. Gibbs says the punishment is political theater; the mayor who pushed for it says she put the public at risk.

• Royal Oak’s seven-member nonpartisan commission voted 5–2 to censure Kim Gibbs after WJBK Fox 2 Detroit footage showed her at the Capitol protest in a red coat, unmasked and standing among the crowd.
• Mayor Michael Fournier called for Gibbs’ resignation, but she refused, arguing only the governor has legal authority to remove her and insisting she broke no laws.
• The Monday, April 27 Zoom meeting ran past 1 a.m. and included over two hours of roughly 100 pre-recorded public comments, most of them critical of Gibbs.

The Origins of the Censure

Mayor Pro Tem Patricia Paruch introduced the censure resolution, with commissioners Sharlan Douglas and Kyle DuBuc backing it. Their argument centered on optics as much as public health: a sitting elected official, seen on local television standing shoulder-to-shoulder with demonstrators outside the Capitol during a statewide emergency, sent a message that undercut the very orders Royal Oak was asking residents to follow. Paruch and her allies framed Gibbs’ appearance as disdain for the guidelines the city itself was enforcing.

The protest Gibbs attended, covered in depth in coverage of thousands of Michigan residents flooding the Capitol against Whitmer’s order, drew people from across the state objecting to the strict lockdown rules imposed as COVID-19 case counts climbed. Gibbs, an attorney and one of only two conservatives on the seven-seat body, was there as a participant, not an observer, and Fox 2’s cameras caught her in the crowd.

Gibbs Digs In

Gibbs has been unapologetic. She says she attended to defend small businesses and their workers, framing her presence as an exercise of First Amendment rights rather than a public-health violation. She also dismissed the severity of the virus outright.

“In my eyes, the scare on the coronavirus is over.”

That line, delivered as Michigan’s stay-at-home order remained in force, became the flashpoint for critics who said a sitting commissioner minimizing the outbreak was exactly the kind of message the censure was meant to answer. Mayor Fournier accused Gibbs of violating lawful state emergency orders and endangering public health, and demanded she resign outright. Gibbs held her ground, telling colleagues the effort to punish her was a partisan attempt to wreck her reputation and political future.

A Reprimand With No Teeth

City officials were clear throughout the process that the censure carries no removal power — Royal Oak’s charter doesn’t give the commission authority to unseat an elected member. It’s a formal, on-the-record scolding and nothing more. Commissioner Randy LeVasseur joined Gibbs as the lone other “no” vote, arguing the resolution amounted to the commission trying to silence political dissent rather than genuinely address public health.

The nearly six-hour session underscored how divided the public comment was, too: of the roughly 100 recorded calls played into the record, the overwhelming majority sided against Gibbs, but the sheer volume — and the hour it took to get through them — showed just how much the episode had become a local flashpoint far beyond a single sidewalk photo.

Gibbs remains on the commission, unmoved by the vote and still defending the trip to Lansing as a matter of principle rather than a mistake. Whether Royal Oak voters see it the same way is a question for her next election, not for a Zoom call that ran past 1 a.m.